Andrew was a promising young defender and spent a short period with the youth team having arrived from the Tottenham Hotspur Youth Academy in 2003. He was given a starting place in the Maunsell Cup semi-final tie against Northampton Town in September 2004, but left for a trial with Barnet. After a short period for the Bees, he joined Aylesbury Town in January 2005 until the end of the season. After 16 appearances for the Ducks, he played for Bishop Stortford and Hemel Hempstead Town the following season. He joined Blackstones of the United Counties League Premier Division, but is thought to have left in 2008.